top of page
Search

Etsy vs. Shopify: Where Should You Start Your Small Business?

6 days ago
5 min read

If you're opening your first online shop, my answer is almost always the same: start on Etsy. Then add Shopify once people are coming to you on their own.


"Should I sell on Etsy or Shopify?" is the question I get most from new small business owners. It makes sense, because both cost money, both take time to set up, and picking the wrong one can feel like a waste of both.


Below I'll walk through what each platform actually gives you, every fee you'll pay, what those fees add up to at different income levels, and how to know when it's time to move or add a second store.


Etsy vs. Shopify: what's the real difference?

Etsy is a marketplace. Shopify is a tool for building your own website. That one difference affects everything else, from fees to how you find customers.


Etsy already has the shoppers

People go to Etsy already wanting to buy handmade, vintage, or custom things. You don't have to convince them to show up. If your listing is set up well and someone searches for what you make, you can get found in your first week.


Shopify is all you

With Shopify you get your own website. There are no other shops sitting right next to your listing, you control how everything looks, and you keep every customer's email address. That last part matters more than most people realize, because an email list is the one audience no platform can take away from you.


Etsy fees explained

Etsy has no monthly bill. You pay when you list something and when it sells, which is why it's easier on a brand new shop. These are the fees for a US shop.



On a $25 sale with free shipping, that's about $2.83 in fees, so you keep around $22.17. The shipping part catches a lot of people. If you charge $5 for shipping, Etsy takes 6.5% of that too.


Shopify fees explained

Shopify charges a monthly fee whether you sell anything or not, plus a fee on every card sale. Here's the Basic plan, which is where most small shops start (Shopify pricing).


Then there are the extras. Apps, a paid theme, and your domain name are all optional, but most stores end up paying for a few. Budget for them before you compare the two platforms.


Etsy vs. Shopify fees: what you'd actually pay

If you make under about $5,000 a year, Etsy costs less. Above that, Shopify's fees are lower, but only if you can bring in the buyers yourself.


These numbers assume $25 orders, Shopify Basic paid yearly, and no ads, apps, or offsite ad fees.



The reason is simple. Etsy's fees grow with every sale, while Shopify's plan stays at $348 a year no matter what, and its card fee is a lower percentage. When you're small, that flat fee hurts. Once you're selling steadily, it becomes the cheaper option.


One thing this table doesn't show is where those sales came from. On Etsy, a lot of them came from people already shopping there. On Shopify, every one of them came from you.


Etsy offsite ads: the fee most sellers don't know about

Etsy advertises your listings on sites like Google and social media. If someone clicks one of those ads and buys from you within 30 days, Etsy takes an extra cut of that order (Etsy Help).


  • 15% of the order if your shop made under $10,000 in the last 12 months

  • 12% once you've passed $10,000

  • Capped at $100 per order


Add that to the regular fees and a single ad sale can lose around 25% to Etsy. If your profit margin is under about 30%, those sales barely make you anything.


The good news is you can turn them off if your shop has never made $10,000 in a year. Go to Shop Manager, then Settings, then Offsite Ads. Once you pass $10,000, they're on for good.


Shopify's big catch: you bring the buyers

Nobody stumbles onto a Shopify store. There's no search bar full of shoppers browsing for handmade earrings, so every visitor has to come from something you did.


That usually means posting on Instagram, pinning on Pinterest, sending emails, or paying for ads. If you already have a following, that's great. If you don't, a brand new Shopify store can be very quiet, and you're still paying for it every month.


This is the part people skip when they say Shopify is "more professional." A nice website with no traffic doesn't make sales.


When to start on Etsy, and when to add Shopify


Start on Etsy if…

  • You're still figuring out what sells

  • You don't have a following yet

  • You make handmade, vintage, or custom products

  • You'd rather spend your time making than marketing


That's most people at the start, and that's fine. Etsy lets you test products and prices without paying a monthly bill while you figure it out.


Add Shopify when…

  • Customers start asking "do you have a website?"

  • Your Instagram or Pinterest is already driving sales

  • You're consistently selling more than about $5,000 a year

  • You want to own your customer list and email them directly


You can also do both

You don't have to pick one forever. A lot of sellers keep Etsy for finding new customers and send their own followers and repeat buyers to their Shopify store. Etsy brings people in, and your website is where they come back.


My honest answer

If you're just getting started, open an Etsy shop. Make your first sales, see what people actually buy, and learn how to price your products. Then build your own website once people are coming to you on their own.


Shopify is a great platform. It's just not usually the right first step.

If you're setting up your Etsy shop and want it done right from the start, that's exactly what my Etsy Shop Set-up program is for. You can also grab my free First 30 Days on Etsy planner to map out your first month.


Etsy vs. Shopify FAQ


Is Etsy or Shopify better for beginners?

Etsy, for most people. It has shoppers built in and no monthly fee, so you can start selling before you have an audience.


Is Etsy cheaper than Shopify?

For smaller shops, yes. With $25 orders, Etsy costs less until you're making around $5,000 a year. After that, Shopify's fees are lower.


How much does Etsy take from a sale?

About 11% on a typical US sale with no ads. On a $25 order, that's roughly $2.83 between the listing fee, the 6.5% transaction fee, and payment processing.


How much does Shopify cost per month?

The Basic plan is $39 a month, or $29 a month if you pay for the year. Card sales cost 2.9% + 30¢ on top of that.


Can I sell on Etsy and Shopify at the same time?

Yes. Lots of sellers use Etsy to find new customers and Shopify for repeat buyers and their social media followers.


Can I turn off Etsy offsite ads?

Only if your shop has never made $10,000 in a year. You'll find it under Shop Manager, then Settings, then Offsite Ads.


Sources

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page